After observing discrepancies between tracking on the N2YO website and actual observation, I asked some questions and figured out that there may be some initial confusion lingering over which object is which. I'm told that catalog ID 43016 is most accurate and after checking, it does agree with my observations.
So for anyone that has N2YO bookmarked to track AO-91, here is the link to what I believe is the correct tracking: http://www.n2yo.com/?s=43016
I know N2YO has things labelled differently, but I have sent him a message to check on it. Just wanted to let folks know in case they are also having similar problems. N2YO is a great resource, in my opinion, and I've been using it for tracking the birds going on 5 years now. My thanks to N2YO!
73, Kevin N4UFO