Scott (& others), Whether you subscribe to elements, or your program auto-updates, you can usually look and see how 'fresh' your element set values are. Most tracking programs let you see the values in use for each particular satellite. Some have verbose descriptions, others show a compact format.
Looking at an example 2-line element set from the Amsat.org website, you see the number 08318, in position as the "epoch" or the instant of validity. Any element set is just a snap-shot of one moment in an orbit. Future positions are just 'running the clock forward'. This 08318 means
year=2008, day = 318, or the 318th day of 2008 (13 Nov)
ISS \ / 1 25544U 98067A 08318.67148292 .00010913 00000-0 84099-4 0 6455 2 25544 051.6436 330.0973 0003809 346.3452 121.7147 15.72579683572054
So this data set for ISS was generated last week, but until something changes the 'status-quo' it should be fairly accurate. When the shuttle docks, there are slight changes, but generally that same data stays fairly accurate. However the shuttle significantly slowed down to dock. That old shuttle data set is no longer useful. At 17,500 miles/hour you may not notice right away the effect of ISS docking from the ground. Possibly a difference of seconds may show up eventually, but many of us don't keep our clocks set that close. By the time the next set of radar-derived keps for ISS show up, they will most accurately describe the current 'docked' configuration of the orbiting complex.
For a quick tutorial on understanding Keplerian Elements by N6NKF: http://www.amsat.org/amsat-new/tools/keps_detail.php
P.S. Excellent viewing opportunity this evening for ISS/STS126. I use http://www.heavens-above.com for nice tables and sky charts. Hope your weather is clear - should be spectacular... The station complex has never been bigger, it should be really bright !!!
Enjoy /;^)