Thank you for sharing your feelings about this.
I strongly disagree that this is some sort of "war".
After being elected in 2019, Patrick and I were simply not allowed to participate. We were denied access to corporate communications and records. This was done by the majority members of the board, starting the day the results were announced. Some of these problems continue to the present day.
Some of the people that did this are running for another term. When elected representatives refuse to even meet with people that think differently than they do, then something is very wrong. Refusing to hold board meetings hurts AMSAT. The organization doesn't run itself.
Patrick and I have zero power and have caused zero harm. The only thing we've brought to the party is sunlight.
"please elect people that will allow regular AMSAT board meetings" and "please elect people that will not spend member money on secretly hired law firms" is all we are asking for from the membership. This is not the equivalent of "warfare". These things aren't even that controversial. We just want to do our jobs. We need your help.
I am very sorry it's an uncomfortable subject. I honestly do not think you would have preferred us to hide it for another year. I don't think you would want all of us to do completely nothing for month after month because the majority simply picked up the ball and walked off the field.
That's not a war. That's a forfeit.
-Michelle W5NYV
On Tue, Jul 21, 2020 at 7:40 PM john--- via AMSAT-BB amsat-bb@amsat.org wrote:
One of my ham radio friends asked me a few weeks ago, "What is going on with AMSAT?" It's nothing short of an all out civil war. And it is nasty and it's tearing us apart.
With so many posts and so many twists and turns, it is hard to determine the root cause of the War. You have to stand way back to have any chance of finding out. If you take the time, the real issues becomes clear.
The War on the amsat-bb seemed to subside a few days ago when members started talking about the ballots they were receiving in the mail. Maybe the thought was, if I just cast my vote, the problem will go away. Nothing could be farther from the truth. Patrick and Michelle are not on the ballot and they will still be on the Board after the election is over.
My ballot and the candidate's statements arrived yesterday. And so did the oversize postcard sent out by 3 of the candidates. I read the statements and have been reading the candidate's comments on other social media platforms. Some of the candidates talked about some of the War issues. Some said they would like to see regular Board meetings. One candidate posted that he would cast the third vote required to demand General Board meetings be held regularly! That's about as bold as it gets in the candidate's statements. The same person promised to do some other things as well if elected; some helpful and some not, in my opinion. But at least he said them..
A while back, a member made a post about who he would vote for. He documented everyone's credentials, experience, past efforts with AMSAT along with comments about personal interactions, if any. Those are good things to consider. But what about the future? What issues does the candidate deem important and how does he or she plan to deal with them?
To me. the most important issue for AMSAT is to find a way to bring our Civil War to an end. And that would include negotiating an agreement with all parties that will restore civility and respect for all members, a culture that is open to all ideas regardless of who is suggesting them, as much transparency as the law permits along with fiscal responsibility and accountability. For the past week I've pondered how to do this and came up with a plan that has a chance of working. But I'm not running for a Board position (and never will) so I will defer to the candidates to come up with their own ideas.
I challenge each candidate to address the issue and detail a plan to deal with it. Forget the general statements. There are things that must happen for the War to end. And if someone with a high school education and few accomplishments can do it, all of you should be able to solve this problem with ease. My vote will go to the candidates with the best plans. I urge others to wait a bit before casting their votes. Let's see what happens!
73, John K8YSE _______________________________________________ Sent via AMSAT-BB@amsat.org. AMSAT-NA makes this open forum available to all interested persons worldwide without requiring membership. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author, and do not reflect the official views of AMSAT-NA. Not an AMSAT-NA member? Join now to support the amateur satellite program! Subscription settings: https://www.amsat.org/mailman/listinfo/amsat-bb