Honestly, all I use to great success at my vacation summer QTH is a regular dual band Arrow, not even the big one, and an AZ rotor. I made a mount so,I could angle he antenna permanently at about 30-40 degrees and I let Satpc32 software handle the rotation control. It worked very well considering until,I ended up buying a new G5500 for the home QTH and repaired the old 5400 for the lake house so now I use he same antenna but with AZ and EL control and that works extremely well?

I’ve tried many antennas including a pair of M2 egg beaters which never worked that well for me. 73 Rick, W2JAZ