Source of AO-85/Fox-1 elements?
What is the source of the AO-85/FOX-1 orbital elements I see through the usual channels? Kelso's Celestrak isn't carrying them. When I inquired, I learned that it's US policy not to release elements for any object associated with an NRO launch -- and AO-85 was launched with USA 264, 2015-058A, #40964.
Kelso already asked for an exception but was denied. But NRO isn't doing a very good job of hiding our satellite, as current elements are readily available on the (German) Heavens-Above site:
1 40967U 15058D 17278.51421614 .00000880 00000-0 11831-3 0 01124 2 40967 064.7745 244.1947 0178987 037.6014 323.7456 14.75520632016072
Even the *primary* (spook) payload USA264 also has current elements there:
1 40964U 15058A 17278.82038009 0.00000000 00000-0 00000-0 0 00 2 40964 63.4416 239.2742 0066660 175.8104 184.1896 13.40733320 01
though these probably came from the dedicated worldwide team of volunteer SEESAT observers that for decades has provided the dual public service of producing their own element sets for US spy satellites and making fools of the US spooks in the process.
And a close comparison will show that USA264 and AO-85 aren't even in the same orbit, which makes the non-publication policy even sillier than it first appeared.
"When everything is classified, nothing is classified..."
--Phil
AMSAT pulls the keps from the Space-Track database. I believe the policy for secondary payloads on classified missions allows only the satellite owners or their designated representatives to do so. We can then redistribute them ourselves.
Of course, this policy does not make much sense. Russia and China know exactly where all of our classified satellites are. The only consequence is that we're inconvenienced. My favorite iOS tracking app pulls solely from Celestrak, so I have to use another app for NO-84 and AO-85.
73,
Paul, N8HM
On Fri, Oct 6, 2017 at 8:22 PM, Phil Karn karn@ka9q.net wrote:
What is the source of the AO-85/FOX-1 orbital elements I see through the usual channels? Kelso's Celestrak isn't carrying them. When I inquired, I learned that it's US policy not to release elements for any object associated with an NRO launch -- and AO-85 was launched with USA 264, 2015-058A, #40964.
Kelso already asked for an exception but was denied. But NRO isn't doing a very good job of hiding our satellite, as current elements are readily available on the (German) Heavens-Above site:
1 40967U 15058D 17278.51421614 .00000880 00000-0 11831-3 0 01124 2 40967 064.7745 244.1947 0178987 037.6014 323.7456 14.75520632016072
Even the *primary* (spook) payload USA264 also has current elements there:
1 40964U 15058A 17278.82038009 0.00000000 00000-0 00000-0 0 00 2 40964 63.4416 239.2742 0066660 175.8104 184.1896 13.40733320 01
though these probably came from the dedicated worldwide team of volunteer SEESAT observers that for decades has provided the dual public service of producing their own element sets for US spy satellites and making fools of the US spooks in the process.
And a close comparison will show that USA264 and AO-85 aren't even in the same orbit, which makes the non-publication policy even sillier than it first appeared.
"When everything is classified, nothing is classified..."
--Phil _______________________________________________ Sent via AMSAT-BB@amsat.org. AMSAT-NA makes this open forum available to all interested persons worldwide without requiring membership. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author, and do not reflect the official views of AMSAT-NA. Not an AMSAT-NA member? Join now to support the amateur satellite program! Subscription settings: http://www.amsat.org/mailman/listinfo/amsat-bb
participants (2)
-
Paul Stoetzer -
Phil Karn