Jim,

 

In this case it wouldn’t have helped since I wouldn’t have gotten to the point of reading the documentation for a long time since we already had everything running.  As I mentioned in another email, it does point out the benefit of the peer review.  Although this is not a classic example, Stephen was able to look at our problem with a fresh perspective, unbiased by our prior experience with the receiver and spot the problem that we should all have thought of but didn’t.  I’ve seen this exact thing happen over and over.  The fact that Stephen was not involved in the receiver project that was his strength.  Knowing the CAN-Do network inside and out was of course a huge plus too!

 

73,

 

Juan

 


From: Jim Sanford [mailto:wb4gcs@amsat.org]
Sent: Sunday, September 16, 2007 5:28 PM
To: Dave hartzell
Cc: juan-rivera@sbcglobal.net; eagle@amsat.org; Robert McGwier
Subject: Re: [eagle] Re: YAHOO!!!! IT WORKS!!!!

 

Guys:
There's a lesson here:   DOCUMENTATION

Juan expected/assumed one thing, the CAN-Do! widget was something else.  Other teams will go through exactly the same issue.  SO, it appears we need to add some documentation to each WIDGET in terms of serial number, address, and probably a handful of other things I don't know about. 

Let's learn from this experience.

Juan, thanks to you and your team for perservering.

Stephen, thanks for your prompt support on a short fuse.

This kind of response and mutual support is exemplary, and what it will take to get Eagle on orbit.

Thanks & very 73,
Jim
wb4gcs@amsat.org


Dave hartzell wrote:

Wow, this is a relief.  I'm glad it was something simple....after all
the hunting and pecking we did yesterday, I'm glad it was something so
simple.
 
I guess when the term "bus" is used, an address as probably key to
getting to your destination.  ;-)
 
Dave
 
On 9/16/07, Juan Rivera <juan-rivera@sbcglobal.net> wrote:
  
All,
 
We need to take up a collection to buy Stephen a large hero badge.  He fixed
the problem and the receiver is now sitting on my bench happily receiving a
signal.  The new CAN-Do module that he sent me had a different address than
the old one and the old files were addressing the initialization
instructions to a non-existent device.  All we have to do is change the
address field in the initialization files and everything is fine.
 
Whew!  The train of life in back on the tracks!
 
73 to all,
 
Juan
 
 
_______________________________________________
Via the Eagle mailing list courtesy of AMSAT-NA
Eagle@amsat.org
http://amsat.org/mailman/listinfo/eagle