Pete,
I have been using an inside antenna for many years. The rafters in the attic made it difficult to install anything but a ground plane up there so I converted an extra bedroom into an antenna farm. This enabled me to put in beams for 2M and 70cm with a Yaesu rotor. I am able to copy beacons down to the horizon. The house has vinyl siding so that might help. Older homes with aluminum siding might have more problems. There are also special "energy saving" shingles around that have a layer of aluminum embedded in a conventional asphalt shingle, these might also be more of a problem. Like you I also found that at my location I believe the performance of the inside antennas is very close to outside antennas on 70cm and below with LEO satellites. This is empirical data. It is also nice not to have to worry about wind, snow, ice and rain or climb around on a tower to make adjustments.. My antennas and preamps look like new.
I suspect that in the unlikely event we ever have another HEO satellite or on frequencies above 70cm the inside antenna might be more or a problem. All my work with HEO sats back in the glory days used outside antennas so I do not have any empirical data.
If the signal strength is high enough almost anything can work. I Think about that every time I use my smart phone in an elevator to check my email.
W9KE Tom Doyle
On Sun, Mar 6, 2016 at 6:18 PM, Pete Parisetti [email protected] wrote:
Having read about some mighty satellite antenna installations in the attic
- one in particular... - I wanted to run a few tests of my local conditions
before going ahead with a similar project.
I built a GP for 146 MHz using wire hangers (SWR flat across the entire 144 and 430 MHz bands....), placed it in my attic and fed it with 45' of Ecoflex 10.
On a dry day, today I could hear the FO-29 beacon from about 10 degrees to about 10 degrees. I find this extraordinary. I don't know if ther roof slates will attenuate more when wet (this may be a urban legend...), but on a day like today I think the difference attic/outside is almost negligible.
73 Pete MM0TWX _______________________________________________ Sent via [email protected]. AMSAT-NA makes this open forum available to all interested persons worldwide without requiring membership. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author, and do not reflect the official views of AMSAT-NA. Not an AMSAT-NA member? Join now to support the amateur satellite program! Subscription settings: http://www.amsat.org/mailman/listinfo/amsat-bb