Sure simple antennas work. DL7VTX just finished a vacation where he made many QSOs from PJ7, J7, PJ6, and FS on SO-50 with a TH-D7 and a 5/8 wave telescoping 2m whip. Let's keep in mind he was operating from islands, likely in spots where he had an excellent view of the horizon over the ocean and with virtually no RF noise. In other areas, a whip is not going to work as well.
You are right that a whip should work pretty well on Fox-1A, 1C, EO-80, etc.
But it depends what you are doing. Are you attempting to stretch the footprint to work sub-1 degree passes of AO-7 or FO-29 into Europe or South America? Are you trying to collect telemetry or command a satellite from AOS to LOS? If so, you probably want something like this new M2 offering.
You contributed to this thread because you wanted to make sure that people don't think you need a $500 antenna system to work LEOs - and that is true, but on the same token, a $15 tape measure antenna will produce disappointing results in most cases if someone is trying to make QSOs on SO-50.
73,
Paul, N8HM
On Sunday, March 8, 2015, Clint Bradford clintbradford@mac.com wrote:
... how many were made on SO-50 ...
You are missing the point - ESPECIALLY with the ISS and the upcoming AMSAT-NA FOX-1A project with its 2M downlink, providing up to 400mW TX power, and approximately 6db stronger receive signal than having a 440 downlink.
SO ... if one's more "simple" antenna is doing well now with SO-50 and the ISS, just imagine how exciting an educational project FOX-1A is going to be!
Clint Bradford K6LCS http://www.work-sat.com
Sent via AMSAT-BB@amsat.org javascript:;. AMSAT-NA makes this open forum available to all interested persons worldwide without requiring membership. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author, and do not reflect the official views of AMSAT-NA. Not an AMSAT-NA member? Join now to support the amateur satellite program! Subscription settings: http://amsat.org/mailman/listinfo/amsat-bb