Hi Brian,
I would choose RHCP on VHF in case you want to receive NOAA APT, and LHCP
on UHF so that it's cross polarized with VHF, to minimize cross-talk and
desense.
Most of the amateur satellites are linearly polarized, so RHCP vs. LHCP
won't make a difference for those. You'll have about +1 dBi maximum gain
for all cases.
It wouldn't be my first choice for working satellites, but of course it
depends on what application you have in mind.
-Stephen
N8URE